Columbia International Affairs Online: Working Papers

CIAO DATE: 10/2010

The Meaning of Left-Right in Latin America: A Comparative View

Nina Wiesehomeier

July 2010

The Helen Kellogg Institute for International Studies

Abstract

During recent years the so-called left turn across the Latin American continent has stimulated research seeking to explain this resurgence, accompanied by a lively debate about distinct variants of the left, broadly conceived as “good” and “bad,” social democratic and populist. This paper goes beyond this simplistic distinction: It explores the substantive policy content of left and right in Latin American countries using original expert survey data of policy positions of political parties and presidents in 18 countries and furthermore compares these left-right estimates with results from elite surveys. The examples discussed underscore the need to take policy positions on particular policy dimensions into account and show that caution is recommended in the use of the general left-right axis.