Columbia International Affairs Online: Working Papers

CIAO DATE: 11/2009

Man in his Natural State: The New World and Locke's Second Treatise

Joel A. Konrad

September 2009

Institute on Globalization and the Human Condition, McMaster University

Abstract

Over the past four decades an effort has been made to relieve John Locke’s writing of its central position in the foundation of the “American Republic,” as historians of political philosophy have tended to devalue his role in the pantheon of America’s founding philosophers (Huyler 1995; Pocock 1975; Bailyn 1967). Although we have a robust historiography that considers the question of Locke in America, we have surprisingly few scholarly studies on the role of America in Locke’s thought, particularly of the conceptual imagery of the Americas and its peoples in Locke’s Second Treatise (Bailyn 1967; Pocock 1975). The studies that do consider this connection do not situate his work into a broader historiography concerning the impact of the New World on Europe during the three centuries after its discovery. Instead, scholars have largely approached the question from the perspective of political theory and with the relatively limited goal of explicating his political thought more clearly. In this paper, I am interested in reading Locke as a crucial moment in the larger impact of the New World on Europe during the three centuries after its discovery.