CIAO DATE: 03/02


Critical Review

Critical Review

Summer 1998 (Vol.12 No.3)

Are We All Dialecticians Now? Reply to MacGregor and Friedman

By Chris Matthew Sciabarra

Abstract

In his critique of Ayn Rand: The Russian Radical, David MacGregor argues that my book trivializes dialectical method. He fails to notice the many nondialectical assumptions that pervade contemporary social theory and practice. Dialectics, as a context-sensitive methodological orientation, can provide tools for a better grasp of systems and processes in the real world--the goal, as I understand it, of the "post-libertarian" approach Jeffrey Friedman advocates.